This kind of spread turns even some gold-tier players into MLB The Show 25 Stubs usable options, making the Twins a surprisingly competitive theme team.

How to Use Captains Strategically
While going all-in with 26 players from the same team to unlock full Tier 3 boosts is exciting, it’s not always the optimal competitive strategy. Here’s a smarter, more balanced approach:

Slot in 5–10 players from the same team.

Unlock Tier 1 or Tier 2 captain boosts.

Mix these boosted players with your existing God Squad.

This lets you retain meta favorites like 99 José Ramírez, Beltrán, or Hodges while boosting select cards that benefit most from captains. For example, the Cleveland Guardians’ Tier 1 buff grants +5 to power and clutch stats, making players like Bo Naylor near-elite hitters with minimal investment.

The key takeaway? You don’t have to rebuild your entire squad around captains. Selective investing can yield powerful returns.

Best Theme Teams in MLB The Show 25 Right Now
Here are some standout teams to consider:

Boston Red Sox

Deep offensive lineup: Ortiz, Manny Ramirez, Yoshida, Veritek

Dual captains boost hitting and pitching

Buffs include Contact, Power, and Clutch (+6)

New York Yankees

Smaller boosts, but with already elite base cards

Babe Ruth and Luis Gil captains offer balanced buffs

Great overall synergy and MLB The Show 25 Stubs for sale power potential